If you happen to’re trying to find a few of the most effective pizza in Plains, PA, look no additional than Florio’s Pizza. This old-school takeout joint is a real hidden gem, serving up among the best Pan Fried Sicilian (PFS) pizza within the space. My current go to to Florio’s was a memorable expertise, from the nice and cozy hospitality to the unmistakable sizzle of the pizza frying in metal pans.
A Traditional Takeout Spot with Genuine Attraction
Florio’s is a small, no-frills pizzeria that gives a partial view into the kitchen, the place you may catch a glimpse of the Bakers Delight ovens and seasoned metal pans—the identical sort I take advantage of at residence! Certainly one of my favourite issues about visiting conventional pizzerias is soaking within the environment, and at Florio’s, you may truly hear the pizza frying because it crisps up within the pan. That alone units the stage for an genuine Pan Fried Sicilian expertise.
A Heat Welcome from the Proprietor
One of many highlights of my go to was assembly Mike, the proprietor, who took the time to step out from the again and chat with me. We had an unimaginable dialog about pizza, farming, and native meals spots. It’s at all times a pleasure to attach with true pizza lovers, and this was a kind of real moments that I received’t neglect.
The Pizza: A Completely Balanced Pan Fried Sicilian
Now, let’s speak concerning the star of the present—the Pan Fried Sicilian pizza.
- Crust: Fried to an ideal medium brown, providing a crispy edge and backside whereas sustaining a gentle and tender middle.
- Sauce: A textured sauce that wasn’t overly chunky however supplied nice consistency and balanced taste. This was one of many extra sauce-heavy PFS pizzas I’ve had, but it surely labored completely!
- Cheese: A mild-flavored cheese mix, probably mozzarella and cheddar, although I can’t say for positive. The portion was beneficiant with out overwhelming the sauce.
- Total Stability: The ratio of crust, sauce, and cheese was spot on, making for a well-rounded and pleasing chunk.

Why Florio’s is a Should-Go to for Pizza Lovers
For anybody in the hunt for genuine Pan Fried Sicilian pizza in Plains, PA, Florio’s is a must-visit. The crispy-yet-tender crust, flavorful sauce, and high quality cheese mix make for a very basic PFS expertise. Mix that with the pleasant service and old-school vibes, and also you’ve obtained one of many finest pizza spots in Plains, PA.
If you happen to love hidden gem pizzerias, make certain to take a look at my full video assessment dropping quickly! Till then, do your self a favor and seize a field of Florio’s Pan Fried Sicilian—you received’t remorse it!

Wish to know what the most effective pizza sauce is? I examined, ranked, and scored all of them! Listed below are my Pizza Sauce Rankings!
READ: What’s the Distinction Between Outdated Forge Pizza and Pan Fried Sicilian Pizza?
Score the Pizza
- Restaurant: Florio’s Pizza
- Deal with: 107 W Carey St, Wilkes-Barre, PA 18705
- Dine In/Take Out: Take Out
- Pizza Ordered: Pan Fried Sicilian Pizza with Onions
- Date: March 2025
Score Class | Score Rating |
---|---|
Crust | 7.7 |
Sauce | 7.4 |
Cheese | 8.1 |
Style | 7.5 |
Crispy/Cooked Correctly | 7.9 |
Worth | 7.7 |
Total Score | 7.7 |
Pizza is Just like: Spare Time Pizza, Again Street Ale Home, Plains Pub
Help my work by beginning your Amazon transport journey utilizing THIS LINK! It prices you nothing, however helps NEPA Pizza Evaluation help small companies and buy pizza provides and gear to maintain creating free content material for you!